VKC ScienceChemistry for written exams Telegram

UPSC Civil Services (Mains)

Chemistry optional

  • 2 papers
  • 250 marks each
  • 3 h per paper
  • 5 of 8 questions, Q1 and Q5 compulsory

Paper I covers physical and inorganic chemistry.

UPSC Civil Services (Mains), Chemistry optional · 2017 · Paper I

Q1(b). Most probable speed from the Maxwell distribution

  • 10 marks
  • Answered
Question

For an ideal gas, the distribution law of molecular speed is,
[dN_c=4π N((m)/(2π k_BT))^(3/2)c² e^-mc²/2k_BT dc,]
where,
dN_c = Number molecules within the speed range c and (c+dc).
N = Total number of molecules.
m = Molecular mass.
T = Temperature in Kelvin scale.
Derive the expression of most probable speed of this gaseous system.

Answer in brief

cₘₚ=√(2k_BT/m)=√(2RT/M), the speed at which the distribution function has its maximum.

Key points

  • Function to maximise. The fraction of molecules per unit speed is f(c)=1/N(dN_c)/(dc)=4π((m)/(2π k_BT))^(3/2)c²e^-mc²/2k_BT. The most probable speed is the c at which f(c) is a maximum. The constant factor does not change the…
  • (dg)/(dc)=2c e^-mc²/2k_BT+c²(-(mc)/(k_BT))e^-mc²/2k_BT=c e^-mc²/2k_BT(2-mc²k_BT)
  • Set dg/dc=0. c=0 and c→∞ give the minima (f=0). The maximum is at 2-mc²k_BT=0: cₘₚ=√((2k_BT)/(m))=√((2RT)/(M)) (R=N_Ak_B, M=N_Am)
  • dg/dc>0 for c<cₘₚ (the c² rise) and dg/dc<0 for c>cₘₚ (the exponential fall wins).

The full model answer

Written out in full, as it should go in the answer booklet. The solution page with its diagrams follows it.

  1. Function to maximise. The fraction of molecules per unit speed is f(c)=1/N(dN_c)/(dc)=4π((m)/(2π k_BT))^(3/2)c²e^-mc²/2k_BT. The most probable speed is the c at which f(c) is a maximum. The constant factor does not change the position of the maximum, so only g(c)=c²e^-mc²/2k_BT is differentiated.
  2. Differentiate: (dg)/(dc)=2c e^-mc²/2k_BT+c²(-(mc)/(k_BT))e^-mc²/2k_BT=c e^-mc²/2k_BT(2-mc²k_BT)
  3. Set dg/dc=0. c=0 and c→∞ give the minima (f=0). The maximum is at 2-mc²k_BT=0: cₘₚ=√((2k_BT)/(m))=√((2RT)/(M)) (R=N_Ak_B, M=N_Am)
  4. It is a maximum: dg/dc>0 for c<cₘₚ (the c² rise) and dg/dc<0 for c>cₘₚ (the exponential fall wins).
  5. Example, N₂ at 300 K (m=4.653×10⁻²⁶ kg): cₘₚ=2(1.3805×10⁻²³)(300)/4.653×10⁻²⁶=422 m s⁻¹; c=√(8k_BT/π m)=476 m s⁻¹; cᵣₘₛ=√(3k_BT/m)=517 m s⁻¹.
  6. cₘₚ∝√(T/m): the peak moves to higher speed and becomes lower and broader as T rises; a heavier gas has its peak at a lower speed.

Application. the high-speed tail above cₘₚ holds the molecules with enough energy to react, which is why reaction rates rise steeply with temperature; c∝1/√M is the basis of Graham's law of effusion.

Practising this answer? Write it in a Mains test and get it checked by VKC. Civil Services Mains test series · Telegram

Model answer to Q1(b), 2017 Paper I: solution page 3
Solution page 3 of 38