Q8(a). Third law: absolute zero cannot be reached
Use third law of thermodynamics to show that absolute zero of temperature is unattainable.
Answer in brief
Cooling below about 1 K uses alternate isothermal and adiabatic steps between two values of a variable X (such as magnetic field). Because the third law makes S(0,X₁)=S(0,X₂), the two S–T curves meet at T=0, each step is smaller than the last, and T=0 would need an infinite number of steps.
Key points
- the entropy change of any isothermal process between equilibrium states tends to zero as T→0; the entropies of all perfect crystals approach the same value (taken as zero). Hence S(0,X₁)=S(0,X₂) for any two values of a…
- How low temperatures are reached (adiabatic demagnetisation): a paramagnetic salt such as Gd₂(SO₄)₃.8H₂O at about 1 K is magnetised isothermally (field X₁→ X₂; entropy falls, heat leaves to the helium bath), then isolated and…
- S(T,X)=S(0,X)+∫₀^T(C_X)/(T) dT. The field-on curve lies below the field-off curve at every T>0, but by the third law the two meet at T=0 (figure).
- One adiabatic step from (T₁,X₂) to (T₂,X₁) keeps S constant: S(0,X₂)+∫₀^(T₁)C_(X₂)TdT=S(0,X₁)+∫₀^(T₂)C_(X₁)TdT
The full model answer
Written out in full, as it should go in the answer booklet. The solution page with its diagrams follows it.
- Third law (Nernst heat theorem): the entropy change of any isothermal process between equilibrium states tends to zero as T→0; the entropies of all perfect crystals approach the same value (taken as zero). Hence S(0,X₁)=S(0,X₂) for any two values of a variable X (field, pressure).
- How low temperatures are reached (adiabatic demagnetisation): a paramagnetic salt such as Gd₂(SO₄)₃.8H₂O at about 1 K is magnetised isothermally (field X₁→ X₂; entropy falls, heat leaves to the helium bath), then isolated and demagnetised adiabatically (X₂→ X₁ at constant S), so its temperature falls.
- The two curves: S(T,X)=S(0,X)+∫₀^T(C_X)/(T) dT. The field-on curve lies below the field-off curve at every T>0, but by the third law the two meet at T=0 (figure).
- One adiabatic step from (T₁,X₂) to (T₂,X₁) keeps S constant: S(0,X₂)+∫₀^(T₁)C_(X₂)TdT=S(0,X₁)+∫₀^(T₂)C_(X₁)TdT
- Try to reach T₂=0: the right-hand integral vanishes, and with S(0,X₁)=S(0,X₂): ∫₀^(T₁)C_(X₂)T dT=0
- This is impossible: heat capacities are positive at every T₁>0, so the integral is positive. No adiabatic step starting above zero ends at zero.
- Graphically: because the curves converge, each isothermal–adiabatic pair gives a smaller drop in temperature than the one before; an infinite number of steps would be needed. Hence: T=0 cannot be reached in a finite number of steps
Application. nuclear adiabatic demagnetisation has reached 280 pK in silver, very close to zero but never zero; the third law also gives absolute (third-law) entropies from heat-capacity data, used to calculate Δ S°, Δ G° and equilibrium constants.
Practising this answer? Write it in a Mains test and get it checked by VKC. Civil Services Mains test series · Telegram

All parts of Question 8
- 8(a) Third law: absolute zero cannot be reached15 marks
- 8(b) Chelate effect, template effect and entropy in complex stability15 marks
- 8(c) Structure of ferrocene and its MO description10 marks
- 8(d) Electrode reactions of the fuel cell and the lead–acid cell10 marks