VKC ScienceChemistry for written exams Telegram

UPSC Civil Services (Mains)

Chemistry optional

  • 2 papers
  • 250 marks each
  • 3 h per paper
  • 5 of 8 questions, Q1 and Q5 compulsory

Paper I covers physical and inorganic chemistry.

UPSC Civil Services (Mains), Chemistry optional · 2019 · Paper I

Q8(a). Third law: absolute zero cannot be reached

  • 15 marks
  • Answered
Question

Use third law of thermodynamics to show that absolute zero of temperature is unattainable.

Answer in brief

Cooling below about 1 K uses alternate isothermal and adiabatic steps between two values of a variable X (such as magnetic field). Because the third law makes S(0,X₁)=S(0,X₂), the two S–T curves meet at T=0, each step is smaller than the last, and T=0 would need an infinite number of steps.

Key points

  • the entropy change of any isothermal process between equilibrium states tends to zero as T→0; the entropies of all perfect crystals approach the same value (taken as zero). Hence S(0,X₁)=S(0,X₂) for any two values of a…
  • How low temperatures are reached (adiabatic demagnetisation): a paramagnetic salt such as Gd₂(SO₄)₃.8H₂O at about 1 K is magnetised isothermally (field X₁→ X₂; entropy falls, heat leaves to the helium bath), then isolated and…
  • S(T,X)=S(0,X)+∫₀^T(C_X)/(T) dT. The field-on curve lies below the field-off curve at every T>0, but by the third law the two meet at T=0 (figure).
  • One adiabatic step from (T₁,X₂) to (T₂,X₁) keeps S constant: S(0,X₂)+∫₀^(T₁)C_(X₂)TdT=S(0,X₁)+∫₀^(T₂)C_(X₁)TdT

The full model answer

Written out in full, as it should go in the answer booklet. The solution page with its diagrams follows it.

  1. Third law (Nernst heat theorem): the entropy change of any isothermal process between equilibrium states tends to zero as T→0; the entropies of all perfect crystals approach the same value (taken as zero). Hence S(0,X₁)=S(0,X₂) for any two values of a variable X (field, pressure).
  2. How low temperatures are reached (adiabatic demagnetisation): a paramagnetic salt such as Gd₂(SO₄)₃.8H₂O at about 1 K is magnetised isothermally (field X₁→ X₂; entropy falls, heat leaves to the helium bath), then isolated and demagnetised adiabatically (X₂→ X₁ at constant S), so its temperature falls.
  3. The two curves: S(T,X)=S(0,X)+∫₀^T(C_X)/(T) dT. The field-on curve lies below the field-off curve at every T>0, but by the third law the two meet at T=0 (figure).
  4. One adiabatic step from (T₁,X₂) to (T₂,X₁) keeps S constant: S(0,X₂)+∫₀^(T₁)C_(X₂)TdT=S(0,X₁)+∫₀^(T₂)C_(X₁)TdT
  5. Try to reach T₂=0: the right-hand integral vanishes, and with S(0,X₁)=S(0,X₂): ∫₀^(T₁)C_(X₂)T dT=0
  6. This is impossible: heat capacities are positive at every T₁>0, so the integral is positive. No adiabatic step starting above zero ends at zero.
  7. Graphically: because the curves converge, each isothermal–adiabatic pair gives a smaller drop in temperature than the one before; an infinite number of steps would be needed. Hence: T=0 cannot be reached in a finite number of steps

Application. nuclear adiabatic demagnetisation has reached 280 pK in silver, very close to zero but never zero; the third law also gives absolute (third-law) entropies from heat-capacity data, used to calculate Δ S°, Δ G° and equilibrium constants.

Practising this answer? Write it in a Mains test and get it checked by VKC. Civil Services Mains test series · Telegram

Model answer to Q8(a), 2019 Paper I: solution page 35
Solution page 35 of 40