UPSC Civil Services (Mains), Chemistry optional · 2020 · Paper I
Q1(b). Spacing of the (123) planes of an orthorhombic cell
Question
An orthorhombic unit cell has the following parameters: a=0.5 Å, b=1.0 Å, c=1.5 Å. What will be the smallest spacing between two successive 123-planes?
Answer in brief
1/d²=h²/a²+k²/b²+l²/c²=4+4+4=12 Å⁻², so d₁₂₃=0.289 Å (28.9 pm).
Key points
- the plane nearest the origin cuts the axes at a/1, b/2 and c/3. All planes of the family are parallel and equally spaced; the perpendicular distance between two successive planes is d₁₂₃, the plane through O being the first.
- Spacing formula for axes at right angles (the normal to the plane makes angles whose direction cosines are hd/a, kd/b, ld/c, and their squares add to 1): 1dₕₖₗ²=h²a²+k²b²+l²c²
- Substitution: 1d²=1²(0.5)²+2²(1.0)²+3²(1.5)²=4+4+4=12 Å⁻²
- Result: d₁₂₃=(1)/(√(12)) Å, d₁₂₃=0.289 Å=28.9 pm
The full model answer
Written out in full, as it should go in the answer booklet. The solution page with its diagrams follows it.
- Miller indices (123): the plane nearest the origin cuts the axes at a/1, b/2 and c/3. All planes of the family are parallel and equally spaced; the perpendicular distance between two successive planes is d₁₂₃, the plane through O being the first.
- Spacing formula for axes at right angles (the normal to the plane makes angles whose direction cosines are hd/a, kd/b, ld/c, and their squares add to 1): 1dₕₖₗ²=h²a²+k²b²+l²c²
- Substitution: 1d²=1²(0.5)²+2²(1.0)²+3²(1.5)²=4+4+4=12 Å⁻²
- Result: d₁₂₃=(1)/(√(12)) Å, d₁₂₃=0.289 Å=28.9 pm
- Check: each of the three intercepts equals 0.5 Å here, so the (123) plane cuts the three edges at the same distance from O; d is smaller than every intercept, as it must be for the perpendicular.
- Higher orders: planes written (246) have half this spacing (0.144 Å), but they are the second-order reflection from the same (123) planes (2d₁₂₃θ=2λ), not a new set of lattice planes. The spacing between successive 123-planes of the lattice is 0.289 Å.
Application. with Bragg's law, λ=2dθ, the measured angles of an X-ray powder pattern give the set of dₕₖₗ; fitting them to the orthorhombic formula gives a, b and c (indexing the pattern).
Practising this answer? Write it in a Mains test and get it checked by VKC. Civil Services Mains test series · Telegram

All parts of Question 1
- 1(a) Dissociation energies of N₂⁺ and O₂⁺10 marks
- 1(b) Spacing of the (123) planes of an orthorhombic cell10 marks
- 1(c) C_V in terms of U; (∂ C_V/∂ V)_T=0 for an ideal gas10 marks
- 1(d) Phenol–water: two liquid layers and the phase rule10 marks
- 1(e) E°(Ag⁺/Ag) from the equilibrium constant10 marks