Daily answer writing · Sun, 25 Oct, 2026
Packing efficiency of bcc, and why CsCl is 8:8 while NaCl is 6:6
Calculate the packing efficiency of a body-centred cubic (bcc) lattice. Using the radius ratio rule, explain why $\ce{CsCl}$ adopts 8 : 8 coordination whereas $\ce{NaCl}$ adopts 6 : 6 coordination. Is the CsCl structure truly body-centred cubic?
Syllabus: Common to CSE Paper I, IFoS Paper I and Geo-Scientist Mains: solid state, packing in crystals, radius ratio rules, ionic structures.
Model answer
Packing efficiency of bcc
Atoms per unit cell: $8 \times \tfrac{1}{8}$ (corners) $+ 1$ (body centre) $= 2$.
Atoms touch along the body diagonal: $\sqrt{3}\,a = 4r \Rightarrow a = \dfrac{4r}{\sqrt{3}}$.
$$\text{Packing efficiency} = \frac{2 \times \frac{4}{3}\pi r^3}{a^3} = \frac{\frac{8}{3}\pi r^3}{\left(\frac{4r}{\sqrt3}\right)^3} = \frac{\sqrt{3}\,\pi}{8} = 0.680 = \mathbf{68\%}$$
(32% is empty space; compare 74% for ccp/hcp and 52.4% for simple cubic.)
Radius ratio rule
A cation of radius $r^+$ keeps contact with $N$ anions of radius $r^-$ only if $r^+/r^-$ exceeds a limiting value: 0.414 to 0.732 for octahedral (6) and above 0.732 for cubic (8) coordination.
| Salt | r+ (pm) | r− (pm) | r+/r− | Predicted | Found |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CsCl | Cs+ 174 | Cl− 181 | 0.96 | 8 (cubic) | 8 : 8 |
| NaCl | Na+ 102 | Cl− 181 | 0.56 | 6 (octahedral) | 6 : 6 |
The large Cs+ ion can touch eight Cl− ions at the corners of a cube, gaining more Madelung energy. The small Na+ would "rattle" in a cubic hole, so it takes the octahedral holes of a ccp array of Cl−.
Is CsCl bcc?
No. The body-centre ion (Cs+) differs from the corner ions (Cl−), so the two sites are not equivalent. CsCl is a simple cubic lattice with a two-ion basis (Cl at 0,0,0 and Cs at ½,½,½): two interpenetrating simple cubic lattices.
Where the marks are
- Z = 2, body-diagonal relation, and 68% shown step by step (4 marks).
- Limiting radius ratios and correct calculation for both salts (4 marks).
- CsCl is primitive cubic with a basis, not bcc (2 marks). This is the line that separates a good answer from an average one.
- A neat unit-cell sketch of CsCl helps.