VKC ScienceChemistry for written exams Sign in

← Daily answer writing

Daily answer writing · Sun, 25 Oct, 2026

Packing efficiency of bcc, and why CsCl is 8:8 while NaCl is 6:6

Solid state 10 marks about 160 words 7 minutes

Calculate the packing efficiency of a body-centred cubic (bcc) lattice. Using the radius ratio rule, explain why $\ce{CsCl}$ adopts 8 : 8 coordination whereas $\ce{NaCl}$ adopts 6 : 6 coordination. Is the CsCl structure truly body-centred cubic?

Syllabus: Common to CSE Paper I, IFoS Paper I and Geo-Scientist Mains: solid state, packing in crystals, radius ratio rules, ionic structures.

Model answer

Packing efficiency of bcc

Atoms per unit cell: $8 \times \tfrac{1}{8}$ (corners) $+ 1$ (body centre) $= 2$.

Atoms touch along the body diagonal: $\sqrt{3}\,a = 4r \Rightarrow a = \dfrac{4r}{\sqrt{3}}$.

$$\text{Packing efficiency} = \frac{2 \times \frac{4}{3}\pi r^3}{a^3} = \frac{\frac{8}{3}\pi r^3}{\left(\frac{4r}{\sqrt3}\right)^3} = \frac{\sqrt{3}\,\pi}{8} = 0.680 = \mathbf{68\%}$$

(32% is empty space; compare 74% for ccp/hcp and 52.4% for simple cubic.)

Radius ratio rule

A cation of radius $r^+$ keeps contact with $N$ anions of radius $r^-$ only if $r^+/r^-$ exceeds a limiting value: 0.414 to 0.732 for octahedral (6) and above 0.732 for cubic (8) coordination.

Saltr+ (pm)r− (pm)r+/r−PredictedFound
CsClCs+ 174Cl− 1810.968 (cubic)8 : 8
NaClNa+ 102Cl− 1810.566 (octahedral)6 : 6

The large Cs+ ion can touch eight Cl− ions at the corners of a cube, gaining more Madelung energy. The small Na+ would "rattle" in a cubic hole, so it takes the octahedral holes of a ccp array of Cl−.

Is CsCl bcc?

No. The body-centre ion (Cs+) differs from the corner ions (Cl−), so the two sites are not equivalent. CsCl is a simple cubic lattice with a two-ion basis (Cl at 0,0,0 and Cs at ½,½,½): two interpenetrating simple cubic lattices.

Where the marks are

  • Z = 2, body-diagonal relation, and 68% shown step by step (4 marks).
  • Limiting radius ratios and correct calculation for both salts (4 marks).
  • CsCl is primitive cubic with a basis, not bcc (2 marks). This is the line that separates a good answer from an average one.
  • A neat unit-cell sketch of CsCl helps.

Get your answers checked

In the Mains test series you write full papers by hand, upload the copy, and get it back checked by VKC with marks and comments.